摘要
This 2012 chart created by user Dragons flight was based on data from 2011. There are more recent studies including Climate Change: An Information Statement of the American Meteorological Society (Adopted by AMS Council 20 August 2012)
Summary of the opinions from climate / earth scientists regarding climate change.
The Doran & Zimmerman 2009 study archive copy at the Wayback Machine was done for a master's thesis and involved a 9-question survey. The 2009 peer reviewed publication that followed the study reported on 2 of the 9 questions. The study found, in part, that 96.4% of "climatologists who are active publishers on climate change" agree that mean global temperatures have risen "compared with pre-1800s levels", and that 97.4% (75 of 77) agree that human activity "is a significant contributing factor" in temperature change. The study concludes the distribution of answers to those survey questions implies that debate on the "role played by human activity is largely nonexistent" amongst climate experts.
The Anderegg et al 2010 source defined a scientist's expertise as determined by his or her number of climate publications. The top 50 scientists considered CE ("convinced by the evidence" in the terminology of the authors) wrote an average of 408 articles each which were submitted to and successfully published by climate journals. Scientists were counted as UE ("unconvinced by the evidence") if having signed a public "statement strongly dissenting from the views of the IPCC." That resulted in a list of 472 UE scientists, of whom 5 were among the 200 most-published scientists in the study's sample, amounting to 2.5% when the other 195 (97.5%) were counted as CE.
That study's sample included 903 scientists counted as CE ("convinced by the evidence"). Scientists were assumed to be CE when in the list of those credited by the IPCC as having done research utilized by AR4 Working Group I. Such an assumption resulted in a list of 619 names, which, after adjusting for duplication, became a total of 903 when also adding in those who signed one of several statements supporting the IPCC.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2010 http://www.pnas.org/content/suppl/2010/06/07/1003187107.DCSupplemental/pnas.201003187SI.pdf
Author of chart: User:Dragons flight, March 2012
English Wikipedia to Commons Transfer Documentation |
---|
Transferred By | |
---|
Transferred On | 16:13, 11 July 2012 (UTC) |
---|
This template stores the information about this file's transfer from English Wikipedia to Wikimedia Commons, so it can be displayed separately from the main information template form. |
|
本圖片是以PNG、GIF或JPEG格式上傳。然而,其中包含的資料或訊息,應該重新建立成 可縮放向量圖形( SVG)檔案,以更有效率或更準確的方式儲存。如有可能,請上傳本圖片的SVG格式版本。在上傳之後,請修改維基各姊妹計畫中所有使用舊版圖片的條目(列在 圖像連結章節中),替換為新版圖片,並在舊圖片的描述頁中加入 {{Vector version available|新圖片名稱.svg}}模板,同時移除本模板。
|
授權條款
我,本作品的著作權持有者,決定用以下授權條款發佈本作品:
- 您可以自由:
- 分享 – 複製、發佈和傳播本作品
- 重新修改 – 創作演繹作品
- 惟需遵照下列條件:
- 姓名標示 – 您必須指名出正確的製作者,和提供授權條款的連結,以及表示是否有對內容上做出變更。您可以用任何合理的方式來行動,但不得以任何方式表明授權條款是對您許可或是由您所使用。
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0CC BY 3.0 Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 truetrue
Update on December 7 2014
Expansion of comments re upload done today.
(A) Change top line to "Opinions of Climate and Earth Scientists on Human Role in Global Warming".
(B) Change "Significant human impact" to "Significant" and change "Little or no human effect" to "Little or none".
(C) Adjust the Bray + Storch bar so it's 84%/16% rather than 94%/6%.
These changes were discussed on the talk page for the Wikipedia article "Surveys_of_scientists'_views_on_climate_change".
Changes (A) and (B) are as per agreement on that talk page as of December 7 2014.
The adjustment (C) was suggested by user Tillman; user Dragons flight -- the original author of the graphic -- acknowledged that the 94%/6% bar appeared to be an error.
As of December 7 2014 the URL of the talk page discussion was https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Surveys_of_scientists%27_views_on_climate_change#Revised_graphic.
Original attribution of course remains with Dragons flight; user Peter Gulutzan (the person doing this upload) made the above changes and hereby grants all permissions to publish these changes under free licence.